On the Authenticity of De-extinct Organisms, and the Genesis Argument

Simple item page
dc.contributor.authorCampbell, Douglas
dc.date.accessioned2022-08-10T05:24:34Z
dc.date.available2022-08-10T05:24:34Z
dc.date.issued2017en
dc.date.updated2022-07-04T10:17:44Z
dc.description.abstractAre the methods of synthetic biology capable of recreating authentic living members of an extinct species? An analogy with the restoration of destroyed natural landscapes suggests not. e restored version of a natural landscape will typically lack much of the aesthetic value of the original landscape because of the di erent historical processes that created it – processes that involved human intentions and actions, rather than natural forces acting over millennia. By the same token, it would appear that synthetically recreated versions of extinct natural organisms will also be less aesthetically valuable than the originals; that they will be, in some strong sense, ‘inauthentic’, because of their peculiar history and mode of origin. I call this the ‘genesis argument’ against de-extinction. In this article I critically evaluate the genesis argument. I highlight an important disanalogy between living organisms and natural landscapes: viz., it is of the essence of the former, but not of the la er, to regularly reproduce and die. e process of iterated natural reproduction that sustains the continued existence of a species through time obviously does not undermine the authenticity of the species. I argue that the authenticity of a species will likewise be le intact by the kind of arti cial copying of genes and traits that a de-extinction project entails. I conclude on this basis that the genesis argument is unsound.en
dc.identifier.citationCampbell DI (2017). On the Authenticity of De-extinct Organisms, and the Genesis Argument. Animal Studies Journal. 6(1). 61-79.en
dc.identifier.issn1948-352X
dc.identifier.issn2201-3008
dc.identifier.urihttps://hdl.handle.net/10092/104132
dc.language.isoenen
dc.rightsAll rights reserved unless otherwise stateden
dc.rights.urihttp://hdl.handle.net/10092/17651en
dc.subjectDe-Extinctionen
dc.subjectExtinctionen
dc.subjectSpeciesen
dc.subjectAuthenticityen
dc.subject.anzsrcFields of Research::50 - Philosophy and religious studies::5003 - Philosophy::500317 - Philosophy of science (excl. history and philosophy of specific fields)en
dc.subject.anzsrcFields of Research::50 - Philosophy and religious studies::5003 - Philosophy::500304 - Environmental philosophyen
dc.subject.anzsrcFields of Research::31 - Biological sciences::3104 - Evolutionary biology::310412 - Speciation and extinctionen
dc.subject.anzsrcFields of Research::31 - Biological sciences::3104 - Evolutionary biology::310405 - Evolutionary ecologyen
dc.subject.anzsrcFields of Research::50 - Philosophy and religious studies::5001 - Applied ethics::500103 - Ethical use of new technologyen
dc.subject.anzsrcFields of Research::50 - Philosophy and religious studies::5003 - Philosophy::500309 - Metaphysicsen
dc.subject.anzsrcFields of Research::31 - Biological sciences::3104 - Evolutionary biology::310401 - Animal systematics and taxonomyen
dc.titleOn the Authenticity of De-extinct Organisms, and the Genesis Argumenten
dc.typeJournal Articleen
uc.collegeFaculty of Arts
uc.departmentHumanities and Creative Arts
Files
Original bundle
Now showing 1 - 1 of 1
Thumbnail Image
Name:
On the Authenticity of De-extinct Organisms and the Genesis Argu.pdf
Size:
265.02 KB
Format:
Adobe Portable Document Format
Description:
Published version
Download
Collections
Arts: Journal Articles