Pappus Reborn : Pappus of Alexandria and the Changing Face of Analysis and Synthesis in Late Antiquity. (2008)
Type of ContentTheses / Dissertations
Thesis DisciplineHistory and Philosophy of Science
Degree NameMaster of Arts
PublisherUniversity of Canterbury. Humanities
Despite the recent interest in Pappus of Alexandria,the late antiquarian mathematician remains an enigma in the history of mathematics. Only a handful of chapters and fragments of his seminal work, the Collection have been translated into English and there has been little effort to reveal the common mathematical threads therein. To correct this stasis and move Pappian studies into the exploratory stage, I approached the Collection with three questions designed to remove the historiographical biases and avoid the missteps that have persisted over the five-hundred years since Commandino's estate published the first Latin translation. The first question is whether an improved understanding of late antiquity Alexandria and its intellectual environs offer greater insight into Pappus' mathematical style. The second is whether Pappus' infamous exposition on analysis and synthesis from Book 7 of the Collection can be reconciled with propositions from the same book. My final question is that after the reconciliation of proposition and exposition in Book 7, what are the consequences for other books in the Collection that contain otherwise unacknowledged instances of analysis and synthesis? More specifically, will we find consistency between Books 7, 3, and most surprising of all, 2. What is revealed through these questions is the problem modern scholars have with Pappus was never actually about his ability but rather the interference of pedagogy in a field where it is least desired: advanced geometry. Pappus demonstrated thoroughly in Books 2 and 3 that his knowledge of analysis and synthesis was more nuanced than he has been given credit for, involving the social practice of mathematics in Alexandria and the application of arithmetic within a supposedly geometrical method.
RightsCopyright Bronwyn Rideout
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Reviewing the Change: A Comparative Historical Analysis on Immigration Control Policy Change within New Zealand Blackwell, Laura-Alice Caitlin (University of Canterbury. Social and Political Sciences, 2011)Immigration plays a key role in international politics and contributes socially, politically and economically to the functions of a state. Understanding and analysing the immigration policy of a nation is therefore very ...
Change and its management in a health and hospital service : an analysis of the management of change in Canterbury Health Ltd, 1996-2000. Harrington, Matthew Robin (University of Canterbury, 2001)Within this case study, two perspectives upon organisational change are tested within the practice of management undertaken within the context of a New Zealand health and hospital service (HHS) over the last five years. ...
Blampied, N.M. (University of Canterbury. Psychology, 2015)Methodological reform in psychology calls for research to be more idiographic and less dependent on group statistical inference. Recommended alternatives include more extensive use of graphs and visual analysis. This paper ...