One Belt, Competing Metaphors: The Struggle Over Strategic Narrative in English-Language News Media (2018)
This article studies the reception by English-language news media of a strategic narrative deployed by the Chinese state to reposition China in the world. Metaphor analysis is conducted on 816 articles from six countries or regions at the time of a summit in Beijing about the US$5 trillion Belt and Road Initiative to trace the impact of the symbolic work done by China on Western representations. The analysis, combining computer-assisted analysis of the corpus with close analysis of each text, identifies the widespread use of a set of conventional metaphors that reinforce the Chinese state’s geopolitical shift, but also frequent and sometimes highly conscious use of novel metaphors that cast doubt on official Chinese discourse and foreground it as a geopolitical move. The analysis reveals a global English-language imaginary that both extends beyond long-standing stereotypes of China and displays an ironic and critical attitude toward China’s strategic self-positioning. The article argues for the importance of investigating strategic narrative as a rhetorical performance.
CitationOne Belt, Competing Metaphors: The Struggle over Strategic Narrative in English-language News Media Jing Xin, Donald Matheson. International Journal of Communication, vol. 12 (2018)
This citation is automatically generated and may be unreliable. Use as a guide only.
Keywordsstrategic narrative; metaphor analysis; corpus analysis; Belt and Road; China; globalization
ANZSRC Fields of Research47 - Language, communication and culture::4701 - Communication and media studies::470105 - Journalism studies
44 - Human society::4408 - Political science::440807 - Government and politics of Asia and the Pacific
47 - Language, communication and culture::4701 - Communication and media studies::470101 - Communication studies
RightsCopyright © 2018 (Jing Xin and Donald Matheson). Licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial No Derivatives (by-nc-nd). Available at http://ijoc.org.
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
The Chinese writer as empty signifier: a corpus-based analysis of the English-language reporting of the 2012 Nobel Prize in Literature Xin, J.; Matheson, D. (University of Canterbury. School of Language, Social and Political SciencesUniversity of Canterbury. Communication DisordersUniversity of Canterbury. Media and Communications, 2015)This study examines the English-language reporting of the award in 2012 of the Nobel Prize in Literature to the Chinese author, Mo Yan. Through the corpus-based analysis of news reporting in four countries, the study found ...
Ross T (2020)This study explores issues of identity, hybridity and media in an Aotearoa/New Zealand context by analysing Pacific audiences’ affinity for and use of Indigenous Māori media. It makes the case for broadening ethnic ...
Ross T (2019)By looking at how Pacific media producers position themselves in different contexts, this paper identifies complex identity politics within the communities of practice of New Zealand’s Pacific news media production. ...