The (Human) Rights of Nature: A Comparative Study of Emerging Legal Rights for Rivers and Lakes in the United States of America and Mexico (forthcoming) (2021)
An international consensus of scientific experts is now demanding “immediate action” in response to the environmental, climate, and biodiversity crises. But are our legal and regulatory frameworks equipped to respond to the rapid pace of environmental degradation, biodiversity loss and climate change? What incidence is there, transnationally, of laws that seek to protect the Earth from the humans that inhabit it? In the past few decades, there is a growing social, legal, and political movement towards more ecocentric regulation of the planet, where new laws and institutions seek to protect natural resources for their own intrinsic value. In this paper, I consider recent efforts to protect the rights of rivers in the U.S. and Mexico, which are novel and emerging attempts to discover new pathways for enhanced protection of vulnerable waterways. These attempts are being pragmatically driven from the bottom up to the highest levels of the legislature or judiciary as local communities (and sometimes Indigenous Peoples) become increasingly frustrated with apathetic and complacent governmental responses to environmental challenges, using whatever legal tools and processes are available to them. However, rather than an Earth-centred revolution, efforts to protect the rights of nature are distinctly “human”; as communities appeal to human rights laws, and their enhanced constitutional status, to upset the status quo. There are important lessons to be learned from these experiences in other countries in terms of the ability to entrench transformative environmental protections via constitutional hierarchies and the potential for the rights and interests of humans to be both an enabler of, as well as a threat to, nature’s rights.
CitationMacpherson E (2021). The (Human) Rights of Nature: A Comparative Study of Emerging Legal Rights for Rivers and Lakes in the United States of America and Mexico (forthcoming). Duke Environmental Law & Policy.
This citation is automatically generated and may be unreliable. Use as a guide only.
ANZSRC Fields of Research48 - Law and legal studies::4802 - Environmental and resources law::480203 - Environmental law
RightsAll rights reserved unless otherwise stated
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Clavijo Ospina F; Macpherson, Elizabeth (Center for Open Science, 2019)
Towards an Holistic Environmental Flow Regime in Chile: Providing for Ecosystem Health and Indigenous Rights Weber Salazar P; Macpherson, Elizabeth (Cambridge University Press (CUP), 2020)© The Author(s), 2020. A widespread response to the pressures placed on the ecological condition of rivers is the design and implementation of environmental flowregimes in domestic regulatory frameworks for water. Environmental ...
Voice, power and legitimacy: the role of the legal person in river management in New Zealand, Chile and Australia O'Donnell E; Macpherson EJ (Informa UK Limited, 2018)© 2018, © 2018 Engineers Australia. In 2017, rivers in New Zealand, India and Colombia received legal rights and were granted the status of legal persons. The increased legal powers, often a result of groundbreaking ...