Knotted wire fences are fabricated on specialised machines. The input material is typically galvanised steel wire. However, the quality of the input wire used by the Fence Producer is beyond control of the Machine Manufacturer. The problem is that wire strand breakages have been reported during fabrication and subsequent field erection. This is an issue for the Fence Producer because of the lost productivity, and the potential for reputation (brand) damage for both the Manufacturer and Producer. While existing standards do exist for wire, even wire that meets these standards is known to fail during fence fabrication. Thus there is a need to better understand how the quality of wire affects the manufacturability of fences, and to identify, or if necessary create, a test for wire quality that is able to be conducted by Fence Producers. In this research, samples were obtained from known good and failed fences and wire coils, and subjected to a variety of physical and metallurgical tests. These were then statistically examined and compared to the known fate of the fence, to determine the sensitivity of the test. Four potential tests were evaluated: Tensile strength (UTS), ductility, 3-point bending, microstructural, impact energy, plus a fifth novel new test called linear torsional ductility (LTD). From these tests, it was evident that the linear torsional ductility test was the most sensitive and reliable indicator for wire quality. This paper is part of a collection, with companion papers examining material properties of wire, microstructure, impact energy for wire, knot performance, and the testing of whole fences.