Node Network Computer Modelling and a Simple Hand Calculation Compared with Contemporary High Rise Evacuation Case Study Data (2012)
Type of ContentTheses / Dissertations
Thesis DisciplineFire Engineering
Degree NameMaster of Engineering in Fire Engineering
PublisherUniversity of Canterbury. Civil and Natural Resources Engineering
Tall buildings are becoming more common in the modern built environment and the method of evacuating or moving to a place of safety using the stairs is still the primary means of egress. Typically designers use tools such as computer models and hand calculations to predict the time taken for occupants to evacuate to an exit or place of safety. However, increasing trends of obesity, age and a sedentary lifestyle is raising questions about the accuracy of some of the tools. As the tools are based on case study data carried out in the 1980’s.
This research compares evacuation performance of case study buildings to the predictions by Pauls’ simplified hand calculation and the EvacuatioNZ computer model. The comparison uses four multi-storey buildings from the case study data, ranging from 11 to 27 stories high. The research will also investigate the effect of how the building is represented in EvacuatioNZ on the performance of the prediction and make recommendations in best practice for further work.
Results from the comparisons shows EvacuatioNZ is within 15% for total egress time of the case study data in six out of eight of the stairs. The average difference of EvacuatioNZ to the case study is 8.6%. Further comparisons of exit flow rate and descent speed show EvacuatioNZ is within 10% of the case study data in five out of eight of the stairs. Paul’s simplified hand calculation predicts a total egress time which is 6% to 38% shorter than the case study data. Modifying the equation to equalise stair entry delay improves the prediction to a difference of 0.9% to 31%. The modified equation is within 10% in five out of eight stairs.
The comparisons for EvacuatioNZ indicate predictions which are generally with 10-15%. However individual performance is not investigated and this area should be fully investigated to answer concerns about contemporary occupants and their ability to descend multiple flights of stairs. Further work should include a larger range of data, particularly exploring building height and population.
Given the recommendations are followed and more data becomes available for further work to support this research; EvacuatioNZ could be used as a tool for predicting evacuations in multi-storey buildings. Pauls’ hand calculation is not recommended for predictions of multi-storey evacuations without a safety factor. Differences between the prediction and case study result were improved with a modification of the equation to account for the case study stair entry times.
Keywordshigh rise evacuation; evacuation case study; egress; evacuation modelling; EvacuatioNZ
RightsCopyright Garth Stephen Hay
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Application of a Data Mining Process Model: A Case Study- Profiling Internet Banking Users in Jamaica Mansingh, G.; Rao, L.; Osei-Bryson, K.; Mills, Annette (2010)Internet banking has become widely available in Jamaica and yet there have been few studies to understand the characteristics of its users. For banks to improve their service and similar services it becomes imperative ...
Spearpoint, M.J. (University of Canterbury. Civil and Natural Resources Engineering, 2009)Functional testing of any model is a vital step in demonstrating that its predictive capabilities are working appropriately; correspond as expected to the circumstances being modeled and where further work should be directed. ...
INCORPORATING THE EVACUATION DECISION MODEL INTO AN EGRESS SIMULATION PROGRAM AND ASSESSMENT OF NEW ZEALAND PRE-TRAVEL SCENARIOS Retana, E (University of Canterbury, 2015)Pre-evacuation time can be defined as the time between the first cue and when the population starts evacuating. The Evacuation Decision Model (EDM) considers the evacuation decision process over time and predicts the ...