Measuring voluntary and reflexive cough strength in healthy individuals. (2016)
Type of ContentTheses / Dissertations
Thesis DisciplineSpeech and Language Sciences
Degree NameMaster of Science
PublisherUniversity of Canterbury
Introduction: Several studies have evaluated citric acid cough reflex in healthy individuals and neurologically impaired patients. These studies have been instrumental in providing evidence for its use as a validated tool in bedside swallowing evaluations, enabling the identification of patients at risk of silent aspiration. However, inter- and intra-rater reliability for perceptual measurements of strength of coughing is sub-optimal and there are no established objective methods for measuring strength of reflexive coughing. The aim of this study was to objectively evaluate voluntary and reflexive cough strength in healthy individuals. Methods: Fifty-four healthy individuals, aged 50 years and over, participated in this study. Participants performed ‘strong’ and ‘weak’ voluntary coughs and underwent suppressed cough reflex testing using the face-mask method and incremental doses of citric acid at doses of 0.4, 0.8, 1.2 and 1.8 Mol/L. Peak and area under the curve (AUC) measurements were taken for pressure, airflow, and acoustics. Twenty-nine sets of data, where participants produced a C2 response to three doses of citric acid, were included for final analysis. Results: Repeated-measures ANOVA revealed a significant trial effect for reflexive cough, with the second cough in the C2 sequence being smaller than the first, for all 6 measures (pressure: peak p < .01, AUC p < .01; flow: peak p < .01, AUC p < .01; acoustic: peak p = .04 and AUC p < .01). However, there was no significant effect of citric acid dose on strength of reflexive coughing (pressure: peak p = .65, AUC p =.86; flow: peak p = .95, AUC p = .10; acoustic: peak p = .93, AUC p = .93). Repeated-measures ANOVA also revealed a significant effect of type of voluntary cough, with strong coughs having greater values than weak coughs for all 6 measures (p < .01). There was also a significant trial effect of voluntary cough in the C2 sequence, with the second cough being weaker than the first for 4 of the measures (p < .01 for peak and AUC pressure; p < .01 for peak flow and AUC acoustic). Paired t-tests demonstrated that strong voluntary coughs were stronger than reflexive coughs for all measures (p <.01). Conclusions: This research suggests that all six outcome measures were sensitive to measuring changes in coughing strength. The significant difference between strong voluntary coughs and reflexive coughs supports existing research suggesting that assessment of voluntary coughing strength does not provide accurate information about the strength of the reflexive coughing. There was an effect of cough sequence, cough 1 or 2, for both voluntary and reflexive coughing. This might indicate that the first reflexive cough is the most important in terms of airway protection and clearance. There was no effect of concentration of citric acid on strength of suppressed coughing: once the reflex was elicited, coughing strength was stable regardless of stimulus dose. This suggests that either cortical augmentation of voluntary coughing produces a response much greater than the reflexive airway protective response, or that cortical control cannot suppress sensitivity of coughing, but can suppress strength of coughing, at increasing concentrations of citric acid. Alternatively, it may imply that a suppressed cough reflex is an all-or-nothing response, but there is potential that a true reflexive cough, stimulated by aspiration, would show a dose-response effect.
RightsAll Rights Reserved
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Validation of speech-language therapists’ perceptions of reflexive cough strength against objective measures of peak flow, pressure and acoustics Chittleborough, Jennifer (University of Canterbury, 2020)Introduction: Clinicians routinely use subjective ratings of reflexive coughing strength to make judgements about an individual’s ability to protect their airway in the event of aspiration. It is therefore important to ...
Zawawi, Nor Shahrina (University of Canterbury. Department of Communication Disorders, 2010)Cough is a motor act of the laryngeal and respiratory systems. Features of coughing have been considered in the examination of respiratory, swallowing and voice disorders. Although some voice disorders have been linked to ...
Cough reflex following orotracheal intubation : presence and recovery of the cough reflex after extubation and validity of cough reflex testing. Kallesen, Molly (University of Canterbury, 2016)Post-extubation dysphagia is well documented in the Intensive Care Unit (ICU) population, particularly following prolonged intubation (≥48 hours). Identifying patients with dysphagia is important as these individuals are ...