Kant's Departure from Hume's Moral Naturalism (2007)

View/ Open
Type of Content
Theses / DissertationsThesis Discipline
PhilosophyDegree Name
Master of ArtsPublisher
University of Canterbury. Philosophy and Religious StudiesCollections
Abstract
This thesis considers Kant's departure from moral naturalism. In doing so, it explores the relationship between ethics, naturalism, normativity and freedom. Throughout this exploration, I build the case that Kant's ethics of autonomy allows us to make better sense of ethics than Hume's moral naturalism. Hume believes that morality is ultimately grounded in human nature. Kant finds this understanding of ethics limiting. He insists that we are free - we can critically reflect upon our nature and (to an extent) alter it accordingly. This freedom, I contend, renders the moral naturalist's appeal to nature lacking. Of course, a Kantian conception of freedom - some form of independence from the causal order - is fairly unpopular in contemporary circles. In particular, a commitment to naturalism casts doubt on such a notion of freedom. I argue with Kant that such a conception of freedom is essential to the conception of ourselves as rational agents. The critical turn, unlike naturalism, warrants this conception of freedom, accommodating the point of view of our rational agency. It thus allows Kant's ethics of autonomy to better grasp certain key elements of morality - normativity and our agency - than Hume's moral naturalism.
Keywords
Philosophy; Kant (Immanuel); Hume (David); naturalism; science; ethics; morals; morality; normativity; agency; freedom; desire; reason; rationality; autonomy; heteronomy; sympathy; justice; ends; means; ideal; happiness; duty; right; wrong; inclination; motive; metaphysics of morals; moral epistemology; kingdom of ends; Blackburn (Simon); Korsgaard (Christine); Allison (Henry); Darwall (Stephen); Förster (Eckart); Kuehn (Manfred)Rights
Copyright Josiah Paul SaundersRelated items
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
-
Close personal relationships, duty, moral rights and ethical caring
Mason, Carolyn (1999)Close personal relationships require that two people want to have a relationship with each other because of each other's attributes and want each other's lives to go well. These desires, and the belief that their friend ... -
Ethical clothing and issues in visual texts: how persuasion knowledge influences maladaptive responses in ethically inclined consumers.
Perumbally, Femi (University of Canterbury, 2019)Research on ethical decision- making often focuses on mainstream consumers and the ways in which they justify attitude- behaviour gaps to manage a consistent image for the self and society. Although research on ethical ... -
Against Lewis on ‘Desire as Belief’
Campbell, Douglas (Philosophy Documentation Center, 2017)David Lewis describes, then attempts to refute, a simple anti-Humean theory of desire he calls ‘Desire as Belief’. Lewis’ critics generally accept that his argument is sound and focus instead on trying to show that its ...