Learning outcomes of speech audiometry virtual patient use for expert and novice audiology students (2013)

Type of Content
Theses / DissertationsThesis Discipline
AudiologyDegree Name
Master of AudiologyPublisher
University of Canterbury. Department of Communication DisordersCollections
Abstract
Rationale: Audiology student training in New Zealand faces many difficulties with a limited number of qualified instructors and suitable external placements. With a continued shortage of audiologists in New Zealand, new methods of training need to be introduced and implemented. One solution is through the use of realistic, computer-based virtual patient simulators (VPS). HIT Lab New Zealand in conjunction with the University of Canterbury has designed a VPS for New Zealand audiology students. A speech audiometry component is to be developed based on best practice recommendations, and needs to be validated.
Method: Two studies, one with 18 Master of Audiology (“expert”) and another with 18 (“novice”) undergraduate students, were evenly divided into simulator and non-simulator user groups. Simulator users had to complete 5 virtual patient cases in addition to the non-simulator users’ requirement to refer to provided lecture notes and speech audiometry protocols. Novice students were assessed on declarative, procedural and retained knowledge of speech audiometry; expert students were additionally assessed on training transfer. The intervention period was set at two weeks, and the retention assessment at four weeks post-intervention. Results: Expert students who used the simulator significantly improved their training transfer skills. No significant differences were found between and within groups for declarative knowledge and procedural knowledge. Training transfer and procedural knowledge were retained for both groups, but only non-simulator users retained declarative knowledge. Novice students who used the simulator significantly increased their declarative knowledge. Both groups’ procedural knowledge significantly regressed post-intervention. Declarative and procedural knowledge were retained for both groups.
Implications: Simulator use appears to accelerate learning outcomes otherwise achievable through traditional learning methods, and does depend on the users’ existing knowledge base. Regular use may be necessary to retain desired learning outcomes. Improvements (e.g., more detailed feedback systems) are to be incorporated into the simulator, and sole reliance on the simulator for learning is not recommended. Future research into more holistic aspects of virtual patient use within the field of audiology and allied health care is warranted.
Keywords
Speech audiometry; audiology; virtual patient simulators; computer-based learning; simulations; learning; expert students; novice students; New Zealand; procedural knowledge; declarative knowledge; knowledge retention; training transfer; healthcare learningRights
Copyright Gerard WilliamRelated items
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
-
Formative feedback in a virtual patient simulator for clinical audiology training
Guard, Lynda May (University of Canterbury. Communication Disorders, 2013)The aim of this study was to examine the effectiveness of different types of feedback on learning pure-tone audiometry using a simulator. Participants were 51 undergraduate students in the Department of Communication ... -
Immersive education: virtual reality in clinical audiology: a pilot study of the effectiveness of a new patient simulator program on audiology students’ performance on case history tasks
Howland, Sarah Caroline (University of Canterbury. Communication Disorders, 2012)Purpose: Hearing loss is a common problem worldwide, and there is an ever- increasing need for more audiologists to be trained. Unfortunately, audiology students cannot always get the clinical experience they need during ... -
Evaluating the Use Of A Virtual Reality Patient Simulator an An Educational Tool In An Audiological Setting
Sanderson, Elizabeth Anne (University of Canterbury. Communication Disorders, 2013)There is currently an international shortage of Audiologists (McIntyre, 2010). Audiology is a professional degree undertaken at a postgraduate level at most universities around the world. Students have training in anatomy ...