The application of an audited self-management approach to manage nutrient losses in the Hurunui River catchment. (2015)
Type of ContentTheses / Dissertations, Theses / Dissertations, Electronic Thesis or Dissertation
Thesis DisciplineWater Resource Management
Degree NameDoctor of Philosophy
PublisherUniversity of Canterbury. Waterways Centre for Freshwater Management
AuthorsSimpson, Craigshow all
Water quality impairment is becoming an increasing problem in Canterbury, and throughout New Zealand. In North Canterbury, the Hurunui River has been associated with elevated nutrient levels. Not only are elevated nutrient levels a threat to the environmental and cultural values of the area, they also threaten the economic and social aspirations of the community. The community has aspirations to intensify land use in the catchment by increasing the area of irrigated land. To manage nutrient levels in the catchment and to ensure the goals of the community are realised the Hurunui and Waiau Regional Plan sets forth a requirement that an audited self-management (ASM) approach be applied in the region, which is identified in the Canterbury Water Management Strategy as a key tool for the management of water quality.
This study investigates the application of an ASM approach in the Hurunui River catchment and by the use of semi-structured interviews seeks to identify the ASM features and institutional arrangements key stakeholders in the catchment are willing to support. The majority of the key features of an ASM approach are supported in the catchment including governance arrangements, farm environment plans, audits, enforcement mechanisms and effective communication measures. There were areas of divergence in the stakeholders’ opinions however, with differences relating to who administers the enforcement programme, and the public reporting of audit results.
The institutional arrangements supported by the interview participants in the application of an ASM approach are compared to the design features outlined by Elinor Ostrom (1990). The majority of the institutional arrangements supported by stakeholders align with Ostrom’s features including: the freedom of resource users to make their own day-to-day choices; the desire for monitoring; the increasing severity of sanctions on those non-complying resource users; the need for conflict-resolution mechanisms; and that management collectives should retain the freedom to frame their own rules. An area which does not align with these design features was the hesitation of some organisation representatives to allow land users to have direct input into the rules governing the application of an ASM approach.
The research identifies obstacles to the effective application of ASM. Specifically the issues of scientific uncertainty, the promotion of economic over environmental values, and the feeling of lack of involvement felt by some stakeholders, are identified as significant obstacles. To overcome these issues solutions are offered including further water quality monitoring, the promotion of further stakeholder interaction and the continuation of discussions to find an equitable solution to nutrient allocation concerns. Finally, the research presents several recommendations for the consideration of those undertaking the implementation of an ASM approach in the Hurunui River catchment and elsewhere, these include agreement upon the final boundaries for management groups, further investigation into management group governance and data management systems, ensuring audits are undertaken by fully trained and accredited auditors, ensuring that audit results are reported in a manner than generates corrective action, and providing opportunities for land users to frame the rules for an ASM approach.
Keywordscollaborative management; water quality; audited self-management; Ostrom; Canterbury Water Management Strategy; nutrient management; Hurunui River; water management
RightsCopyright Craig Simpson
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Weastell, Lynda (University of Canterbury, 1994)The Resource Management Act (RMA) 1991 is a much discussed and frequently criticised piece of legislation in New Zealand. The RMA 1991 is much discussed because it is part of a substantial reform of New Zealand's resource ...
Lumsden, John; Hendtlass, Charles (Centre for Advanced Engineering, University of Canterbury, 2000)This publication is a revised and updated version of 'Hazardous Wastes: Appropriate Technologies for New Zealand', originally included as Part 3 in Our Waste: Our Responsibility, published by CAE in 1992. This publication ...
Centre for Advanced Engineering (Centre for Advanced Engineering, University of Canterbury, 1993)Proceedings of a Seminar held 20 February 1992 at the School of Engineering University of Canterbury