Predicting attitudinal and behavioral responses to COVID-19 pandemic using machine learning (2022)

View/ Open
Type of Content
Journal ArticlePublisher
Oxford University Press (OUP)ISSN
2752-6542Language
enCollections
- Science: Journal Articles [1179]
Authors
Abstract
At the beginning of 2020, COVID-19 became a global problem. Despite all the efforts to emphasize the relevance of preventive measures, not everyone adhered to them. Thus, learning more about the characteristics determining attitudinal and behavioral responses to the pandemic is crucial to improving future interventions. In this study, we applied machine learning on the multi-national data collected by the International Collaboration on the Social and Moral Psychology of COVID-19 (N = 51,404) to test the predictive efficacy of constructs from social, moral, cognitive, and personality psychology, as well as socio-demographic factors, in the attitudinal and behavioral responses to the pandemic. The results point to several valuable insights. Internalized moral identity provided the most consistent predictive contribution—individuals perceiving moral traits as central to their self-concept reported higher adherence to preventive measures. Similar was found for morality as cooperation, symbolized moral identity, self-control, open-mindedness, collective narcissism, while the inverse relationship was evident for the endorsement of conspiracy theories. However, we also found a non-negligible variability in the explained variance and predictive contributions with respect to macro-level factors such as the pandemic stage or cultural region. Overall, the results underscore the importance of morality-related and contextual factors in understanding adherence to public health recommendations during the pandemic.
Citation
Pavlović T, Azevedo F, De K, Riaño-Moreno JC, Maglić M, Gkinopoulos T, Donnelly-Kehoe PA, Payán-Gómez C, Huang G, Kantorowicz J, Birtel MD, Schönegger P, Capraro V, Santamaría-García H, Yucel M, Ibanez A, Rathje S, Wetter E, Stanojević D, van Prooijen J-W, Hesse E, Elbaek CT, Franc R, Pavlović Z, Mitkidis P, Cichocka A, Gelfand M, Alfano M, Ross RM, Sjåstad H, Nezlek JB, Cislak A, Lockwood P, Abts K, Agadullina E, Amodio DM, Apps MAJ, Aruta JJB, Besharati S, Bor A, Choma B, Cunningham W, Ejaz W, Farmer H, Findor A, Gjoneska B, Gualda E, Huynh TLD, Imran MA, Israelashvili J, Kantorowicz-Reznichenko E, Krouwel A, Kutiyski Y, Laakasuo M, Lamm C, Levy J, Leygue C, Lin M-J, Mansoor MS, Marie A, Mayiwar L, Mazepus H, McHugh C, Olsson A, Otterbring T, Packer D, Palomäki J, Perry A, Petersen MB, Puthillam A, Rothmund T, Schmid PC, Stadelmann D, Stoica A, Stoyanov D, Stoyanova K, Tewari S, Todosijević B, Torgler B, Tsakiris M, Tung HH, Umbreș RG, Vanags E, Vlasceanu M, Vonasch AJ, Zhang Y, Abad M, Adler E, Mdarhri HA, Antazo B, Ay FC, Ba MEH, Barbosa S, Bastian B, Berg A, Białek M, Bilancini E, Bogatyreva N, Boncinelli L, Booth JE, Borau S, Buchel O, de Carvalho CF, Celadin T, Cerami C, Chalise HN, Cheng X, Cian L, Cockcroft K, Conway J, Córdoba-Delgado MA, Crespi C, Crouzevialle M, Cutler J, Cypryańska M, Dabrowska J, Davis VH, Minda JP, Dayley PN, Delouvée S, Denkovski O, Dezecache G, Dhaliwal NA, Diato A, Paolo RD, Dulleck U, Ekmanis J, Etienne TW, Farhana HH, Farkhari F, Fidanovski K, Flew T, Fraser S, Frempong RB, Fugelsang J, Gale J, García-Navarro EB, Garladinne P, Gray K, Griffin SM, Gronfeldt B, Gruber J, Halperin E, Herzon V, Hruška M, Hudecek MFC, Isler O, Jangard S, Jørgensen F, Keudel O, Koppel L, Koverola M, Kunnari A, Leota J, Lermer E, Li C, Longoni C, McCashin D, Mikloušić I, Molina-Paredes J, Monroy-Fonseca C, Morales-Marente E, Moreau D, Muda R, Myer A, Nash K, Nitschke JP, Nurse MS, de Mello VO, Palacios-Galvez MS, Palomäki J, Pan Y, Papp Z, Pärnamets P, Paruzel-Czachura M, Perander S, Pitman M, Raza A, Rêgo GG, Robertson C, Rodríguez-Pascual I, Saikkonen T, Salvador-Ginez O, Sampaio WM, Santi GC, Schultner D, Schutte E, Scott A, Skali A, Stefaniak A, Sternisko A, Strickland B, Strickland B, Thomas JP, Tinghög G, Traast IJ, Tucciarelli R, Tyrala M, Ungson ND, Uysal MS, Van Rooy D, Västfjäll D, Vieira JB, von Sikorski C, Walker AC, Watermeyer J, Willardt R, Wohl MJA, Wójcik AD, Wu K, Yamada Y, Yilmaz O, Yogeeswaran K, Ziemer C-T, Zwaan RA, Boggio PS, Whillans A, Van Lange PAM, Prasad R, Onderco M, O'Madagain C, Nesh-Nash T, Laguna OM, Kutiyski Y, Kubin E, Gümren M, Fenwick A, Ertan AS, Bernstein MJ, Amara H, Van Bavel JJ Predicting attitudinal and behavioral responses to COVID-19 pandemic using machine learning. PNAS Nexus.This citation is automatically generated and may be unreliable. Use as a guide only.
Keywords
COVID-19; social distancing; hygiene; policy support; psychology; machine learning; public health measuresANZSRC Fields of Research
52 - Psychology46 - Information and computing sciences::4611 - Machine learning
42 - Health sciences
Rights
All rights reserved unless otherwise statedRelated items
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
-
Dementia and COVID-19 in New Zealand, Chile, and Germany: A Research Agenda for Cross-Country Learning for Resilience in Health Care Systems
Laporte Uribe F; Arteaga O; Bruchhausen W; Cheung G; Cullum S; Fuentes-García A; Castillo CM; Kerse N; Muru-Lanning M; Salinas Ríos RA; Schrott L; Slachevsky A; Roes M; kirk, ray (2021)The COVID-19 pandemic has revealed existing gaps in policies, systems and services, stressing the need for concerted global action on healthy aging. Similar to the COVID-19 pandemic, dementia is a challenge for health ... -
The IceCube Neutrino Observatory, the Pierre Auger Observatory and the Telescope Array: Joint Contribution to the 34th International Cosmic Ray Conference (ICRC 2015)
Aartsen MG; Abraham K; Ackermann M; Adams J; Aguilar JA; Ahlers M; Ahrens M; Altmann D; Anderson T; Ansseau I; Archinger M; Arguelles C; Arlen TC; Auffenberg J; Bai X; Barwick SW; Baum V; Bay R; Beatty JJ; Becker K-H; Beiser E; BenZvi S; Berghaus P; Berley D; Bernardini E; Bernhard A; Besson DZ; Binder G; Bindig D; Bissok M; Blaufuss E; Blumenthal J; Boersma DJ; Bohm C; Börner M; Bos F; Bose D; Böser S; Botner O; Braun J; Brayeur L; Bretz H-P; Buzinsky N; Casey J; Casier M; Cheung E; Chirkin D; Christov A; Clark K; Classen L; Coenders S; Cowen DF; Daughhetee J; Davis JC; Day M; Dembinski H; Desiati P; DeYoung T; Díaz-Vélez JC; Dumm JP; Dunkman M; Eagan R; Eberhardt B; Ehrhardt T; Eichmann B; Euler S; Evenson PA; Fadiran O; Fahey S; Fazely AR; Fedynitch A; Feintzeig J; Felde J; Filimonov K; Finley C; Fischer-Wasels T; Flis S; Fösig C-C; Fuchs T; Gaisser TK; Gaior R; Gallagher J; Gerhardt L; Ghorbani K; Gier D; Gladstone L; Glagla M; Glüsenkamp T; Goldschmidt A; Golup G; Gonzalez JG; Góra D; Grant D; Groh JC; Groß A; Ha C; Haack C; Hallgren A; Halzen F; Hansmann B; Hanson K; Hebecker D; Heereman D; Helbing K; Hellauer R; Hellwig D; Hickford S; Hignight J; Hill GC; Hoffman KD; Hoffmann R; Holzapfel K; Homeier A; Hoshina K; Huang F; Huber M; Huelsnitz W; Hulth PO; Hultqvist K; In S; Ishihara A; Jacobi E; Japaridze GS; Jero K; Jurkovic M; Kaminsky B; Kappes A; Karg T; Karle A; Kauer M; Keivani A; Kelley JL; Kemp J; Kheirandish A; Kiryluk J; Kläs J; Klein SR; Kohnen G; Koirala R; Kolanoski H; Konietz R; Koob A; Köpke L; Kopper C; Kopper S; Koskinen DJ; Kowalski M; Krings K; Kroll G; Kroll M; Kunnen J; Kurahashi N; Kuwabara T; Labare M; Lanfranchi JL; Larson MJ; Lesiak-Bzdak M; Leuermann M; Leuner J; Lu L; Lünemann J; Madsen J; Maggi G; Mahn KBM; Maruyama R; Mase K; Matis HS; Maunu R; McNally F; Meagher K; Medici M; Meli A; Menne T; Merino G; Meures T; Miarecki S; Middell E; Middlemas E; Mohrmann L; Montaruli T; Morse R; Nahnhauer R; Naumann U; Neer G; Niederhausen H; Nowicki SC; Nygren DR; Obertacke A; Olivas A; Omairat A; O'Murchadha A; Palczewski T; Pandya H; Paul L; Pepper JA; Heros CPDL; Pfendner C; Pieloth D; Pinat E; Posselt J; Price PB; Przybylski GT; Pütz J; Quinnan M; Raab C; Rädel L; Rameez M; Rawlins K; Reimann R; Relich M; Resconi E; Rhode W; Richman M; Richter S; Riedel B; Robertson S; Rongen M; Rott C; Ruhe T; Ryckbosch D; Saba SM; Sabbatini L; Sander H-G; Sandrock A; Sandroos J; Sarkar S; Schatto K; Scheriau F; Schimp M; Schmidt T; Schmitz M; Schoenen S; Schöneberg S; Schönwald A; Schulte L; Seckel D; Seunarine S; Shanidze R; Smith MWE; Soldin D; Song M; Spiczak GM; Spiering C; Stahlberg M; Stamatikos M; Stanev T; Stanisha NA; Stasik A; Stezelberger T; Stokstad RG; Stößl A; Ström R; Strotjohann NL; Sullivan GW; Sutherland M; Taavola H; Taboada I; Ter-Antonyan S; Terliuk A; Tešić G; Tilav S; Toale PA; Tobin MN; Toscano S; Tosi D; Tselengidou M; Turcati A; Unger E; Usner M; Vallecorsa S; Vandenbroucke J; Eijndhoven NV; Vanheule S; Santen JV; Veenkamp J; Vehring M; Voge M; Vraeghe M; Walck C; Wallace A; Wallraff M; Wandkowsky N; Weaver C; Wendt C; Westerhoff S; Whelan BJ; Whitehorn N; Wichary C; Wiebe K; Wiebusch CH; Wille L; Williams DR; Wissing H; Wolf M; Wood TR; Woschnagg K; Xu DL; Xu XW; Xu Y; Yanez JP; Yodh G; Yoshida S; Zoll M; Aab A; Abreu P; Aglietta M; Ahn EJ; Samarai IA; Albuquerque IFM; Allekotte I; Allison P; Almela A; Alvarez-Muñiz J; Ambrosio M; Aminaei A; Anastasi GA; Anchordoqui L; Andringa S; Aramo C; Arqueros F; Arsene N; Asorey H; Assis P; Aublin J; Avila G; Awal N; Badescu AM; Baus C; Beatty JJ; Becker KH; Bellido JA; Berat C; Bertaina ME; Bertou X; Biermann PL; Billoir P; Blaess SG; Blanco A; Blanco M; Blazek J; Bleve C; Blümer H; Boháčová M; Boncioli D; Bonifazi C; Borodai N; Brack J; Brancus I; Bretz T; Bridgeman A; Brogueira P; Buchholz P; Bueno A; Buitink S; Buscemi M; Caballero-Mora KS; Caccianiga B; Caccianiga L; Candusso M; Caramete L; Caruso R; Castellina A; Cataldi G; Cazon L; Cester R; Chavez AG; Chiavassa A; Chinellato JA; Chudoba J; Cilmo M; Clay RW; Cocciolo G; Colalillo R; Coleman A; Collica L; Coluccia MR; Conceição R; Contreras F; Cooper MJ; Cordier A; Coutu S; Covault CE; Dallier R; Daniel B; Dasso S; Daumiller K; Dawson BR; Almeida RMD; Jong SJD; Mauro GD; Mitri ID; Oliveira JD; Souza VD; Peral LD; Deligny O; Dhital N; Giulio CD; Matteo AD; Diaz JC; Diogo F; Dobrigkeit C; Docters W; D'Olivo JC; Dorofeev A; Anjos RCD; Dova MT; Ebr J; Engel R; Erdmann M; Erfani M; Escobar CO; Espadanal J; Etchegoyen A; Falcke H; Fang K; Farrar G; Fauth AC; Fazzini N; Ferguson AP; Fick B; Figueira JM; Filevich A; Filipčič A; Fratu O; Freire MM; Fujii T; García B; García-Gámez D; Garcia-Pinto D; Gate F; Gemmeke H; Gherghel-Lascu A; Ghia PL; Giaccari U; Giammarchi M; Giller M; Głas D; Glaser C; Glass H; Golup G; González N; Gookin B; Gordon J; Gorgi A; Gorham P; Gouffon P; Griffith N; Grillo AF; Grubb TD; Guarino F; Guedes GP; Hampel MR; Hansen P; Harari D; Harrison TA; Hartmann S; Harton JL; Haungs A; Hebbeker T; Heck D; Heimann P; Hervé AE; Hill GC; Hojvat C; Hollon N; Holt E; Homola P; Hörandel JR; Horvath P; Hrabovský M; Huber D; Huege T; Insolia A; Isar PG; Jandt I; Jansen S; Jarne C; Johnsen JA; Josebachuili M; Kääpä A; Kambeitz O; Kampert KH; Kasper P; Katkov I; Keilhauer B; Kemp E; Kieckhafer RM; Klages HO; Kleifges M; Kleinfeller J; Krause R; Krohm N; Kuempel D; Kunka N; LaHurd D; Latronico L; Lauer R; Lauscher M; Lautridou P; Coz SL; Lebrun D; Lebrun P; Oliveira MALD; Letessier-Selvon A; Lhenry-Yvon I; Link K; Lopes L; López R; Casado AL; Louedec K; Lucero A; Malacari M; Mallamaci M; Maller J; Mandat D; Mantsch P; Mariazzi AG; Marin V; Mariş IC; Marsella G; Martello D; Martinez H; Martraire D; Meza JJM; Mathes HJ; Mathys S; Matthews J; Matthews JAJ; Matthiae G; Maurizio D; Mayotte E; Mazur PO; Medina C; Medina-Tanco G; Meissner R; Mello VBB; Melo D; Menshikov A; Messina S; Micheletti MI; Middendorf L; Minaya IA; Miramonti L; Mitrica B; Molina-Bueno L; Mollerach S; Montanet F; Morello C; Mostafá M; Moura CA; Müller G; Muller MA; Müller S; Navas S; Necesal P; Nellen L; Nelles A; Neuser J; Nguyen PH; Niculescu-Oglinzanu M; Niechciol M; Niemietz L; Niggemann T; Nitz D; Nosek D; Novotny V; Nožka L; Núñez LA; Ochilo L; Oikonomou F; Olinto A; Pacheco N; Palatka M; Pallotta J; Papenbreer P; Parente G; Parra A; Paul T; Pech M; Pȩkala J; Pelayo R; Pepe IM; Perrone L; Petermann E; Peters C; Petrera S; Petrov Y; Phuntsok J; Piegaia R; Pierog T; Pieroni P; Pimenta M; Pirronello V; Platino M; Plum M; Porcelli A; Porowski C; Prado RR; Privitera P; Prouza M; Quel EJ; Querchfeld S; Quinn S; Rautenberg J; Ravel O; Ravignani D; Reinert D; Revenu B; Ridky J; Risse M; Ristori P; Rizi V; Rojo JR; Rodríguez-Frías MD; Rogozin D; Rosado J; Roth M; Roulet E; Rovero AC; Saffi SJ; Saftoiu A; Salamida F; Salazar H; Saleh A; Salina G; Sánchez F; Sanchez-Lucas P; Santos EM; Santos E; Sarazin F; Sarkar B; Sarmento R; Sarmiento-Cano C; Sato R; Scarso C; Schauer M; Scherini V; Schieler H; Schmidt D; Scholten O; Schoorlemmer H; Schovánek P; Schröder FG; Schulz A; Schulz J; Schumacher J; Sciutto SJ; Segreto A; Settimo M; Shadkam A; Shellard RC; Sigl G; Sima O; Śmiałkowski A; Šmída R; Snow GR; Sommers P; Sonntag S; Sorokin J; Squartini R; Srivastava YN; Stanca D; Stanič S; Stapleton J; Stasielak J; Stephan M; Stutz A; Suarez F; Suomijärvi T; Supanitsky AD; Sutherland MS; Swain J; Szadkowski Z; Taborda OA; Tapia A; Tepe A; Theodoro VM; Tibolla O; Timmermans C; Toma G; Tomankova L; Tomé B; Tonachini A; Travnicek P; Trini M; Ulrich R; Unger M; Urban M; Valiño I; Valore L; Aar GV; Bodegom PV; Berg AMVD; Velzen SV; Vliet AV; Varela E; Varner G; Vasquez R; Vázquez JR; Vázquez RA; Veberič D; Verzi V; Vicha J; Videla M; Villaseñor L; Vlcek B; Vorobiov S; Wahlberg H; Wainberg O; Walz D; Watson AA; Weber M; Weidenhaupt K; Weindl A; Welling C; Werner F; Widom A; Wiencke L; Wilczyński H; Winchen T; Wittkowski D; Wundheiler B; Wykes S; Yang L; Yapici T; Yushkov A; Zas E; Zavrtanik D; Zavrtanik M; Zepeda A; Zimmermann B; Ziolkowski M; Zuccarello F; Abbasi RU; Abe M; Abu-Zayyad T; Allen M; Azuma R; Barcikowski E; Belz JW; Bergman DR; Blake SA; Cady R; Chae MJ; Cheon BG; Chiba J; Chikawa M; Cho WR; Fujii T; Fukushima M; Goto T; Hanlon W; Hayashi Y; Hayashida N; Hibino K; Honda K; Ikeda D; Inoue N; Ishii T; Ishimori R; Ito H; Ivanov D; Jui CCH; Kadota K; Kakimoto F; Kalashev O; Kasahara K; Kawai H; Kawakami S; Kawana S; Kawata K; Kido E; Kim HB; Kim JH; Kim JH; Kitamura S; Kitamura Y; Kuzmin V; Kwon YJ; Lan J; Lim SI; Lundquist JP; Machida K; Martens K; Matsuda T; Matsuyama T; Matthews JN; Minamino M; Mukai Y; Myers I; Nagasawa K; Nagataki S; Nakamura T; Nonaka T; Nozato A; Ogio S; Ogura J; Ohnishi M; Ohoka H; Oki K; Okuda T; Ono M; Oshima A; Ozawa S; Park IH; Pshirkov MS; Rodriguez DC; Rubtsov G; Ryu D; Sagawa H; Sakurai N; Scott LM; Shah PD; Shibata F; Shibata T; Shimodaira H; Shin BK; Shin HS; Smith JD; Sokolsky P; Springer RW; Stokes BT; Stratton SR; Stroman TA; Suzawa T; Takamura M; Takeda M; Takeishi R; Taketa A; Takita M; Tameda Y; Tanaka H; Tanaka K; Tanaka M; Thomas SB; Thomson GB; Tinyakov P; Tkachev I; Tokuno H; Tomida T; Troitsky S; Tsunesada Y; Tsutsumi K; Uchihori Y; Udo S; Urban F; Vasiloff G; Wong T; Yamane R; Yamaoka H; Yamazaki K; Yang J; Yashiro K; Yoneda Y; Yoshida S; Yoshii H; Zollinger R; Zundel Z; De Clercq, C; Cruz Silva, AH; de Andre, JPAM; del Pino Rosendo, E; De Ridder, S; de Vries, KD; de Wasseige, G; de With, M; di Lorenzo, V; Haj Ismail, A; Alvarez Castillo, J; Alvez Batista, R; de Mello Neto, JRT; Diaz Castro, ML; Dorosti Hasankiadeh, Q; Vargas Cardenas, B; Valdes Galicia, JF; Torres Machado, D; Torralba Elipe, G; Todero Peixoto, CJ; Suarez Duran, M; Sanabria Gomez, JD; Salesa Greus, F; Rodrigues de Carvalho, W; Pakk Selmi-Dei, D; Martinez Bravo, O; Kuotb Awad, AW; Kukec Mezek, G; Gomez Vitale, PF; Gomez Berisso, M (2015)We have conducted three searches for correlations between ultra-high energy cosmic rays detected by the Telescope Array and the Pierre Auger Observatory, and high-energy neutrino candidate events from IceCube. Two ... -
Sustaining the future through virtual worlds
Gregory S; Gregory B; Hillier M; Jacka L; Schutt S; Ellis D; Stokes-Thompson F; Wood D; Masters Y; Orwin L; Stupans I; Scutter S; Warren I; Steel C; Neuendorf P; Bower M; Miller C; Mathews S; Butler D; Hearns M; Garcia J; Jegathesan JJ; Brown R; Meredith G; Muir-Cochran E; Flintoff K; Grant S; Atkins C; Gaukrodger B; Giovanangeli A; Le Rossignol K; Larson I; Cram A; Linegar D; Wang X; Muir T; Cleland B; Paillat E; Grenfell J; Hay L; Gu N; Williams A; Simoff S; Bogdanovych A; McCarthy A; Farley, Helen (2012)Virtual worlds (VWs) continue to be used extensively in Australia and New Zealand higher education institutions although the tendency towards making unrealistic claims of efficacy and popularity appears to be over. Some ...