Does the Tail Wag the Dog? Evidence from Fund Flow to VIX ETFs and ETNs (2016)
Modern derivatives pricing models develop pricing relationships from the principle of no-arbitrage, assuming that if an arbitrage opportunity were to arise in the market, it would be immediately eliminated by active arbitrageurs. With this assumption, the supply curve for the derivative security is infinitely elastic at the model price, so that effects of fluctuation in supply and demand from non-arbitrageurs are suppressed. In particular, flows of funds into and out of mutual funds and ETFs should not affect market prices for the underlying securities. This article explores whether that assumption holds in the real world for ETFs based on the VIX volatility index, and finds that it doesn't. Examining 13 volatility funds separated into four groups according to whether the focus is on nearby or longer horizons and whether volatility exposure is long or short, the authors show that fund flows respond to observed market volatility, flowing into long (short) exposure funds when the market is calm (volatile). Moreover, the VIX responds to fund flows, rising (falling) when money is flowing into long (short) exposure funds. But the evidence shows that this effect is no stronger, i.e., not unusually destabilizing, in periods of high volatility.
CitationBiałkowski J, Dang HD, Wei X (2016). Does the Tail Wag the Dog? Evidence from Fund Flow to VIX ETFs and ETNs. The Journal of Derivatives. 24(2). 31-47.
This citation is automatically generated and may be unreliable. Use as a guide only.
ANZSRC Fields of Research35 - Commerce, management, tourism and services::3502 - Banking, finance and investment::350208 - Investment and risk management
38 - Economics::3801 - Applied economics::380107 - Financial economics
RightsAll rights reserved unless otherwise stated
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Wei X; Bialkowski, Jedrzej; Dang, Huong Dieu (2022)Motivated by the extremely low level of the CBOE VIX accompanied by the high level of US economic policy uncertainty in the period of late 2016 to the end of 2017, we examine the factors affecting the relationship ...
Bialkowski, J.; Jakubowski, J. (Social Science Research NetworkUniversity of Canterbury. Department of Economics and Finance, 2010)This paper investigates to what extent underlying specific properties together with contract design determine level of trading activity on the Eurex derivative exchange. The study looks beyond systematic reasons extensively ...
Rea WS; Yang L; Rea A (2017)We present four methods of assessing the diversification potential within a stock market, and two of these are based on principal component analysis. They were applied to the Australian stock exchange for the years 2000 ...