Is organic food becoming less safe? A longitudinal analysis of conventional and organic product recalls (2021)
Organic products are often portrayed as a healthy alternative—grown in a sustainable way, often locally and subject to external certification scrutiny. However, recent high-profile cases of contaminated organic food have raised questions about the risks associated with organic produce: is organic produce becoming less safe and more risky? The context for this investigation is in the realm of food product recalls. Based on 2010–2017 panel data from the US on food product recalls (with 2721 observations), this paper compares the volume of recalls (adjusted for the growth of sales) between conventional and organic food. This paper further addresses two food-related risks: design risk (a risk that is present in the development of food; such as the use of unapproved ingredients or the omission of some ingredients on the food label) and process risk (a risk within the supply chain, such as the contamination of food products with salmonella or E. coli). Further comparison is drawn based on food product type (here the paper distinguishes between processed and unprocessed food). The paper demonstrates that organic products are becoming less safe and that organic products are recalled at a higher rate. In comparison to conventional produce, organic produce is more prone to process risk and far less to design risk. Similar conclusions are reached even when the organic produce is analysed from a product type perspective.
CitationChowdhury M, Castka P, Prajogo D, Zhao X, Wood LC (2021). Is organic food becoming less safe? A longitudinal analysis of conventional and organic product recalls. Sustainability (Switzerland). 13(24). 13540-13540.
This citation is automatically generated and may be unreliable. Use as a guide only.
Keywordsconventional food; organic food; supply chains; risk; product recalls
ANZSRC Fields of Research35 - Commerce, management, tourism and services::3509 - Transportation, logistics and supply chains::350909 - Supply chains
35 - Commerce, management, tourism and services::3507 - Strategy, management and organisational behaviour::350712 - Production and operations management
30 - Agricultural, veterinary and food sciences::3006 - Food sciences::300605 - Food safety, traceability, certification and authenticity
30 - Agricultural, veterinary and food sciences::3006 - Food sciences::300604 - Food packaging, preservation and processing
RightsCopyright: © 2021 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Diprose G; Sharp E; Graham R; Lee L; Richardson S; Watkins A; Martin-Neuninger R; Dombroski, Kelly; Scobie, Matthew (MDPI AG, 2020)The COVID-19 pandemic and associated response have brought food security into sharp focus for many New Zealanders. The requirement to “shelter in place” for eight weeks nationwide, with only “essential services” operating, ...
Remote Auditing and Assessment during the COVID-19 Pandemic in New Zealand and China: Learnings from the food industry and guidance for the future Castka, Pavel; Bremer P; Wood L; Mirosa M; Zhao X (2021)This report presents results of a study into the use of remote auditing and assessment during the COVID-19 pandemic. The empirical evidence was collected through interviews with a group of key stakeholders who were all ...
Ahmad, R.; Vargo, J.; Pulakanam, V.; Chowdhury, M. (University of Canterbury. Department of Accounting and Information SystemsUniversity of Canterbury. Management, Marketing, and Entrepreneurship, 2015)The concept of maturity model proposes that a process has a lifecycle, which is assessed on the basis of how the process is defined, managed, measured and transformed over time. A framework to develop supply chain (SC) ...