Effectiveness of strength training interventions on adolescent backstroke swimming performance.

Type of content
Theses / Dissertations
Publisher's DOI/URI
Thesis discipline
Education
Degree name
Doctor of Philosophy
Publisher
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Language
English
Date
2022
Authors
Alshdokhi, Khaled Abdullah S.
Abstract

The scientific literature on swimming often states swimming performance is highly influenced by the strength and muscular power of the upper and lower body. To reduce injury risk and enhance swimming performance, coaches invariably include strength training on land (dryland) or in-water (resisted swimming) as part of their swimmers’ training programmes to further complement actual in-water swimming training. Despite the popularity of strength training prescribed to enhance performance, the quantification of its effectiveness in improving adolescent backstroke performance has received scant scientific attention. The World Health Organization (WHO) defines an adolescent as any person between ages 10 and 19 years old. Physically, the adolescent stage of life is characterised by rapid changes in body size, shape and growth, during which a young person develops from a child to an adult (Howells, 2018). Due to these changes, rather than applying study findings derived from adults, it is important to understand the influence any strength training intervention has specifically on adolescent performance. Therefore, this thesis seeks to determine the extent to which dryland and in-water strength training practices may be beneficial for adolescent backstroke swimmers.

My thesis is composed of four studies addressing performance analysis (Study 1), dryland (Study 2 and Study 3) and in-water strength training (Study 4) interventions of adolescent backstroke swimmers. Using retrospective analysis, Study 1 quantified the annual change in competition performance as backstroke swimmers matured. Almost 10,000 swimming years of accumulated data from New Zealand based swimmers was used to estimate the rate of improvement of male and female swimmers as they aged from 8 to 18 years. Our data set highlighted that swimmers improve their performance times by ~1/3 with a decade of backstroke swimming training (in association with natural growth and maturation processes). During the early competitive years (ages 8 – 10) it is not uncommon to improve close to 10% annually. However, during the middle years (ages 11 – 14) improvements of ~5% are realised, while in the later years (ages 15 – 18) improvements of only 1 – 2% are achieved.

Performance improved with increasing age and we know that strength increases as a function of age, therefore many studies have correlated grip strength with improved sports performance because grip strength is an indicator of overall body strength. Using a randomised controlled trial, Study 2 primarily investigated whether improved grip strength would enhance adolescent 100 m backstroke performance. In addition to 4 hours per week of swimming training, undertaking grip strength training (5 min/session, 4x/week for 8 weeks) successfully improved isometric grip strength by 30 – 36% in the two treatment groups (Powerball n=9, age 11.5 ± 1.6 y, 6 male, 3 female: Stressball n= 8, age 11.6 ± 1.6 y, 5 male, 3 female). Despite this improved grip strength, 100 m backstroke time did not improve. Notably, this was the first training study to quantify grip strength’s effect on backstroke performance.

As higher overall strength has been linked with faster sprinting performance using a randomised controlled trial with 28 adolescent male swimmers (age: 12.6 ± 2.6 years), Study 3 primarily examined whether improved overall strength from a beginners’ dryland training programme (~30 min/session, 3x/week for 8 weeks) would improve 50 and 100 m backstroke performance. Over 8 weeks, the Dryland strength group had small to large strength gains of 13 – 167%. These strength gains transferred to small 4.4% and trivial 1.6% magnitude faster 50 and 100 m backstroke performances, respectively. Importantly, our study showed dryland strength transfer was more effective for shorter, compared to longer, sprint backstroke distances this is in line with previous literature indicating that higher overall strength has been linked with faster sprinting performance (i.e. 50m).

Studies 2 and 3, made use of freestyle trials to compare the resulting findings to those of backstroke. Freestyle was used as a comparison to gain further information on stroke-specific differences in adaptation to the various strength protocols. In both studies, backstroke time trials were conducted first as these were the primary focus of the thesis. Additional analysis revealed that sprint freestyle (50 and 100 m) performance may have benefited from the grip strength training completed in Study 2 and the overall strength training intervention implemented in Study 3. These findings indicate that training interventions are movement specific, potentially explaining the absence of improvement in backstroke swimming performance.

We quantified the transfer of dryland strength gains to swimming performance in Study 2 and 3 but we also wanted to compare the gains from using in-water strength training because in- water strength training is favoured by coaches as it is easier to implement. Using a training study, Study 4 investigated the effects of a combined in-water resisted and assisted training programme (6x 25m sprints, 3x/week for 3 weeks) on adolescents (5 male, 4 female; age 15.4 ± 1.7 years) 50 and 100 m backstroke performance. Over 3 weeks, the in-water resisted and assisted training programme was more beneficial for 100 m (small 3.4% magnitude faster) compared to 50 m (trivial 1.0% magnitude faster) backstroke performance. In contrast to findings from Study 3, Study 4 showed the transfer of in-water resisted and assisted training was more effective for longer, compared to shorter, sprint backstroke distances. This potentially indicates benefits arose from applying resistance over a relatively long work period as was the case in the resisted sprints. Deserving further attention, there was also a trend for combined assisted and resisted backstroke training to be more effective for adolescent females compared to males which may be explained by a relatively lower initial strength and hence a greater potential for strength improvement in the female compared to male swimmers.

It is hoped that this thesis will stimulate research interest in adolescent backstroke swimming. Swimming coaches should use these thesis findings to benchmark the effectiveness of backstroke training programmes and set realistic goals and improvement timeframes based on the age and gender of swimmers. Coaches should prioritise the addition of strength training as an evidence-backed time-efficient praxis to improve performance and implement both dryland and in-water resistance training interventions. Researchers should look to experiment with modifying exercises to enhance strength training interventions and improve the transfer to adolescent backstroke swimmers’ in-water performances from age 10 to 17 years.

Description
Citation
Keywords
Ngā upoko tukutuku/Māori subject headings
ANZSRC fields of research
Rights
All Rights Reserved