Consensus Vide Convention - A review of David Lapoujade, William James: Empiricism and Pragmatism Convention (Duke University Press, 2020). (2021)
Originally published in French in 1997 and finally translated into English, David Lapoujade's William James: Empiricism and Pragmatism (2019) is varnished by the specter of Deleuzean transcendental empiricism. Despite Lapoujade – perhaps the single greatest living French Deleuze scholar – rarely references Deleuze directly in this book, he culls James’s pragmatistic theory of truth by way of a relational ontology of referential becoming by simultaneously tracking in Deleuzean parlance. From the connective synthesis to the disjunctive synthesis, Lapoujade references key facets of Deleuze’s tripartite synthesis of time, bridging these concepts with how, in James’s system, continuities function as givens and empiricism, by way of stream of consciousness, weaves co-penetrations with continuous flows. In turn, William James is as much an archeological disinterring of Deleuze by way of James as it is a recovery of James’s pragmatism from Richard Rorty’s neo-pragmatism – an attempt to supersede Rorty’s sprawling overhang and commanding philosophical shadow. As Lapoujade markedly articulates in the first few pages of his book, he understands Rorty's neo-pragmatism – and, more specifically, Rorty's notion of “conversation” – as incorrectly reducing James's conception of “convention” to “consensus”.
RightsThis work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Book Review The gospels of the manifesto moment: Insurrection after God. A review commentary on: An Insurrectionist Manifesto. Four New Gospels for a Radical Politics . Ward Blanton, Clayton Crockett, Jeffrey W. Robbins, and Noëlle Vahanian. Foreword by Peter Rollins, Preface by Creston Davis, and Afterword by Catherine Keller. (Columbia University Press: 2016) Grimshaw, Mike (University of Canterbury, 2018)A manifesto sets out an impassioned political and social argument, while traditionally the religious equivalent has been a creed. Yet read from the position of a radical theology and secular political theology, the historic ...
Book Review Spinoza and Hegel - Substance and Negativity Gregor Moder (Northwestern University Press: 2017) Gonsalves, Rodrigo (University of Canterbury, 2018)To claim that the field of Philosophy encompasses different lines of thought is nothing but an understatement. Sometimes philosophy can be seen as the ultimate clash of thought boxed into a field. We could name pairs and ...
Book Review Critical remarks on Jan-Werner Müller’s What is Populism? (Princeton: Princeton University Press 2016 ). Shammas, Victor L. (University of Canterbury, 2018)Jan-Werner Müller’s (2016) account of populism purports to establish a minimalistic conception of populism. Populists, on Müller’s account, say that they are (i) against pluralism, and (ii) against corrupted elites. But, ...