Voice, power and legitimacy: the role of the legal person in river management in New Zealand, Chile and Australia (2018)
© 2018, © 2018 Engineers Australia. In 2017, rivers in New Zealand, India and Colombia received legal rights and were granted the status of legal persons. The increased legal powers, often a result of groundbreaking agreements or settlements with Indigenous peoples, may improve environmental protection and river management, but they can also challenge the legitimacy of laws and regulations that protect the rivers. In this paper, we compare the new legal rights with two long-standing uses of legal personality in river management, to explore the effects of legal personality in terms of environmental resource management. We argue that governments must ensure that they get the right balance between giving rivers a voice (and the power to be heard), and creating collaborative governance arrangements that strengthen and maintain community support overtime.
CitationO'Donnell E, Macpherson EJ (2018). Voice, power and legitimacy: the role of the legal person in river management in New Zealand, Chile and Australia. Australasian Journal of Water Resources. 23(1). 1-10.
This citation is automatically generated and may be unreliable. Use as a guide only.
KeywordsLegal personality; river; legitimacy; water resource management
ANZSRC Fields of Research48 - Law and legal studies::4802 - Environmental and resources law::480203 - Environmental law
41 - Environmental sciences::4104 - Environmental management::410406 - Natural resource management
RightsAll rights reserved unless otherwise stated
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Desafíos para la gestión ambiental en Chile: una perspectiva australiana [Challenges for Environmental Water Management in Chile: An Australian Perspective] Macpherson EJ; O'Donnell E (2015)The deterioration of aquatic environments is an increasingly serious problem in Chile, in terms of declining water quality and quantity in the face of growing demands by industry, cities and the impact of climate change. ...
¿Necesitan derechos los ríos? Comparando estructuras legales para la regulación de los ríos en Nueva Zelanda, Australia y Chile Macpherson EJ; O'Donnell E (Pontificia Universidad Catolica de Chile, 2017)In this article we consider what giving rivers ‘legal personality’ might add to existing institutional options for environmental water regulation. We examine this question by studying the regulatory approach adopted for ...
Australia, Wet or Dry, North or South: Addressing environmental impacts and the exclusion of Aboriginal peoples in northern water development O'Neill L; Godden L; Macpherson EJ; O'Donnell E (2016)In view of the drive in policy circles to develop northern Australia and the concomitant dependence on water resources this will involve, this article argues that environmental and distributive justice considerations are ...